EN 10204 3.1 vs 3.2 Certificates: What Valve Buyers Must Demand
Every valve order produces a document package, and the most expensive arguments in that package are almost never about the valve. They are about which certificate the buyer expected. "3.1 or 3.2?" asked after the valves are on the water becomes a commercial negotiation. Asked before the PO, it is one line on a datasheet.
This page explains what EN 10204 certificate types actually are, who signs each one, and how to write the requirement so the document you receive is the document you need.
What EN 10204 actually defines
EN 10204 is the European standard that defines the types of inspection documents supplied with metallic products. For valves, three types matter:
| Type | Who issues it | What it means | Independent verification |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.2 | Manufacturer | Declaration of compliance, with test results from the manufacturer's own non-specific inspection | No |
| 3.1 | Manufacturer's independent inspection department | Inspection certificate with specific test results, signed by someone in the manufacturer's organisation who is independent of the production line | Inside the manufacturer, not outside |
| 3.2 | Manufacturer plus an independent inspection body | Inspection certificate countersigned by an inspection representative independent of the manufacturer - nominated by the purchaser, or acting under a regulatory or project scheme | Yes - outside the manufacturer |
The critical distinction is not "which paper looks more official", it is who is allowed to sign the results. In a 3.1 certificate the signatory is inside the manufacturer but outside production. In a 3.2 certificate there is a second signature from an organisation with no commercial interest in the delivery.
What a valve certificate should contain
A usable certificate for a valve or its component parts carries:
- The standard it is issued to - EN 10204 and the type (2.2, 3.1 or 3.2).
- The manufacturer's name and works address.
- The purchaser's order number and the manufacturer's reference.
- Product description, quantity, and the applicable specification or standard (for example API 6D, ASME B16.34).
- Heat number and chemical composition, matching the heat numbers marked on the valve.
- Mechanical properties from the specific inspection, not a generic table.
- Any additional tests the specification calls for - hardness, impact, NDT, corrosion testing for sour service.
- Signature and, for 3.2, the countersignature and stamp of the independent body.
- Date of issue.
If items 5 and 6 are missing, the document is not traceability - it is a letter.
When a project insists on 3.2, and why
| Situation | What is usually required | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Standard industrial service, soft-seated ball valves | 3.1 | Manufacturer's own independent QA is considered sufficient |
| Sour service (NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156) | 3.1 minimum, 3.2 where the operator specifies | Hardness and chemistry are acceptance criteria, not just records |
| Subsea and high-pressure gas | 3.2 | Failure cost and regulatory scrutiny justify third-party countersignature |
| Hydrogen and oxygen service | 3.1 or 3.2 per project, plus process-specific testing | Material cleanliness and compatibility are safety functions |
| EPC projects with an approved vendor list | Per the ITP, often 3.2 for pressure-retaining parts | The ITP's hold points are what the inspector signs at |
| Replacement parts only | 3.1 is normally accepted | The parts are not creating a new pressure boundary |
The pattern: 3.2 appears where the consequence of a material error is severe and the buyer has no practical way to verify it after the fact. It costs more because a third party has to be present, schedule time, and sign. That cost belongs in the quotation, not in an argument later.
How to write it on the purchase order
Replace "material certificates required" with this level of detail:
- Certificates to EN 10204 type 3.1, or type 3.2 with the inspection body nominated by the purchaser.
- Certificates to cover body, bonnet, ball/disc, stem and, where applicable, bolting and gaskets.
- Heat numbers on the certificate to match the marking on each valve.
- Certificates issued in English, PDF, submitted for review before shipment.
- For sour service: hardness test results and the applicable NACE/ISO clause stated on the certificate, not just a compliance statement.
- For 3.2: the inspection body to be agreed before manufacture starts; notification of the test date so the buyer or its representative can witness.
Two practical points save weeks. First, agree the inspection body early - slots fill. Second, decide whether certificates need to be approved before shipment or simply supplied with the documents; the first can add days to the schedule, the second can leave you with valves you cannot accept.
The three mistakes we see most
| Mistake | What it costs |
|---|---|
| Writing "3.1/3.2 as applicable" and leaving it to the supplier | You receive 3.1, the EPC wanted 3.2, and re-issuing after delivery is close to impossible |
| Asking for 3.2 on a standard item with a short lead time | Either a schedule slip or a premium nobody budgeted |
| Accepting a certificate whose heat numbers do not match the nameplate | Traceability chain broken; typically found at goods receipt or, worse, at commissioning |
Related reading
- Materials and NACE MR0175 for sour service - when hardness and chemistry decide acceptance.
- Third-party inspection on valve orders - how TPI is scheduled and what the inspector signs.
- What to send in a valve enquiry - including the documentation requirement, before pricing.
- DBB vs DIB vs single block - the arrangement question that usually comes first.
Need the document requirement checked before you issue the PO?
Send the valve list and the project's inspection requirement. We will tell you which certificate type each item can carry, which need third-party presence, and where the schedule risk sits.
Request a quote: contact form or websale@sawye.com